Skip to content
Home » Posts » November Climate Cafe- Carbon Capture and Storage in 2024

November Climate Cafe- Carbon Capture and Storage in 2024

By Andrew White

Introduction

This climate cafe focused on the idea of carbon capture and storage. Carbon Capture and Storage has been a previous topic of Aberdeen Climate Action however, as it was a while since the topic was brought up, it is important to revisit to consider advancements in the field. Carbon capture is especially relevant in 2024 as the new Labour government has allocated £22 billion worth of spending to carbon capture technologies in the budget. This month, we had three guest speakers; Ian Phillips from the Energy Transition Advisory who spoke about todays technology, Erik Dalhuijsen- cofounder of Aberdeen Climate Action who discussed issues with the technologies and Jacob Nielsen from RGU who discussed the role of communities in Carbon Capture projects.

Speaker 1- Ian Phillips

Our first speaker was Ian Phillips from the Energy Transition Advisory. Ian discussed how consumption patterns of oil and gas are continuing to increase worldwide (particularly in Asia) hence, it is of great importance that carbon capture technologies are explored. Ian spoke about the use of amines to absorb carbon dioxide. Current amine technology is able to capture up to 95% of carbon emissions (under ideal conditions) and can capture around 10 million tonnes annually. Once captured, the locked in carbon dioxide is immediately transported to a safe location (as it is hazardous) and buried 1-3km underground- often in depleted gas wells.

The main problem with using this method is that despite its relatively low cost ($150 per tonne of CO2), the CO2 still needs to be shipped away (1 million tonnes per year is equivalent to around 50 cargo ships full). Furthermore, energy is needed to compress the amine for transportation- reducing its efficiency and 38 billion tonnes of CO2 is produced annually- which would come at a considerable cost to capture. Other ideas explored included oxyfuel, pre combustion capture, nano filtration and cryogenics however, all of these are extremely cost prohibitive compared to amine based technologies and thus very difficult to perform at scale.

Finally Ian proposed using the CO2 for other uses such as for Sustainable Aviation Fuel in planes, feeding algae to make useful products such as food or using it for chemical manufacturing. These were more viable than the other novel technologies proposed however, due to the high volumes of CO2 annually produced, it would not make a huge dent in our total CO2 output.

Speaker 2- Erik Dalhuijsen

Next, Erik Dalhuijsen spoke about how carbon capture is a largely unproven technology proposed by large oil firms to allow “business as usual”. Erik describes how carbon capture is suggested by oil companies as it gives them influence over energy transition committees and allows them to continue exploiting new fossil fuel projects. Erik spoke about how we should focus on reducing our emissions rather than continuing producing as usual as carbon capture is not a mature enough technology to scale. He also brought up how the IPCC has ten key points on reducing climate change. Carbon capture is not mentioned in any of these points, showing that climate scientists do not believe the idea to be a credible solution. Erik suggests that we should be transtitioning away from oil and gas use instead of using carbon capture to exploit new oil and gas reserves as we cannot risk runaway climate change under ineffective carbon capture however, the issue with that is that these new reserves are worth between 1-4 trillion dollars- energy companies will fight for these. Additionally in the UK, many of our emissions are from the transit and residential sector- where carbon capture will be of no use. Erik discussed how carbon capture is positioned as the “best option” by fossil fuel companies and other corporations such as McKinsey however, they just say that as it allows “business as usual” and increased profits for them. Finally, Erik says that carbon capture has its place as a niche technology for certain uses however, it should not become the norm. He believes that the $22 billion spent on carbon capture by Labour should be spent on other technologies such as electrification of rail as this have proven benefits.

Speaker 3- Jacob Nielsen

Our final speaker this month was Jacob Nielsen from RGU who discussed the input of communities in deciding carbon capture technologies and why they should be consulted. Jacob argued that the effects of carbon capture schemes can be felt locally as well as globally and the need to balance the needs of the global community against local disruption. Furthermore, new technologies can create new unforseen issues (for example, microplastics) which could have a detrimental effect on communities. Jacob then discusses the challenges involved in community outreach. As Carbon Capture and Storage consists of a long, complicated planning process, it is paramount that projects are at a relevant stage for community input in order to ensure clarity for the general population. However, once you get to that stage, it is often too late to go back or add suggestions made by the community. Furthermore, community response is often reactive instead of proactive- leading to a less effective outcome. We should be looking at both the needs of the local and global community yet, often a small, vocal local group can derail a whole project- leading to greater amounts of CO2 released into the atmosphere. Overall, it is very important to involve both the locals and the global communities in the planning process of Carbon Capture plants however, co-ordination between these two interests can be difficult.

Share