Skip to content
Home » Posts » November Climate café – Is IT killing the planet?

November Climate café – Is IT killing the planet?

By Andrew White

Introduction

In this climate cafe, we looked at the subject of both consumer and enterprise IT equipment. This is a particular topical subject given the resources being allocated to the training and running of generative AI models- alongside lofty promises by big tech that AI is going to solve climate change. This month we had three speakers; Dr Keith Skene from the University of Dundee who wrote the book “Artificial Intelligence and the Environmental Crisis: Can Technology Really Save the World?”, Andrew Wright- a Business development manager at ICEX group and Brendan Hyland- the CEO of SeabedDC.

Speaker 1- Dr Keith Skene

Our first speaker was Dr Keith Skene who proposed theories on “overpotimisation” due to technology and AI. Dr Skene explained through a hypothetical analogy of squirrels, optimising their environment and subsequently overbreeding- leading to the collapse of the ecosystem and subsequent squirrel depopulation, that optimising absolutely everything around humans could cause widespread ecological damage and ultimately cause unforseen problems that come back to haunt us. The earth system as a whole is extremely complex- containing many components and variables that dynamically interact with one another. These numerous components and variables end up creating a system that is suboptimal for humans. Yet, this makes the earth system work for other organisms we share the world with.

The dangers of AI is that AI seeks to optimise. Since AI is also programmed by humans, it will seek to optimise and adapt the climate based on what is good for us- not for other organisms. Like the squirrel analogy, this can lead to issues for other species. We need a certain degree of subopimiality with an AI-led climate strategy. A posed way to do this is through technology- using Internet of Things (IOT) sensors that monitor emergence and non-linearity and help introduce “suboptimal” conditions.

Another proposal made by Dr Skene is to change the template for AI. Currently, AI is designed to act like a human- in that it will optimise and think solely about itself. Instead, Dr Skene proposes a “swarm intelligence”- as seen in nature that could be a better template for future AI. In the swarm, it is assumed that a larger group comes together and makes a decision based upon differing viewpoints. An example is how different tree, plant and fungi species are all linked within forests through a so-called “wood wide web”. This “wood wide web” allows for different species to share resources and grow and adapt to changing environmental conditions in a co-ordinated, multi stakeholder fashion. Through designing AI to be more collaborative, rather than out for itself, Dr Skene recognises that it will make the necessary “suboptimal” decisions.

Speaker 2- Andrew Wright

Our next speaker is Andrew Wright from ICEX- a company that helps businesses recycle and repurpose old IT equipment. Andrew Wright explains that although the internet has revolutionised our lives, it has a real-world environmental footprint. If the internet was a country, it would be the 4th largest polluter. Furthermore, AI is set to increase this- Googles energy use have increased by 51% since 2019- largely due to AI. It is projected that for tech giants to meet their 2030 goals on AI, 90 gigawatts of extra electricity is required each year in the USA alone. As it takes time to add renewable capacity, this will likely come from fossil fuel sources.

Additionally we have a IT waste crisis. Currently, we throw away 62 million tonnes of IT waste per year and only recycle 17% of it. When these electronics break down, metals like lead, mercury and cadmium leak out into the environment. Batteries also explode in landfill- burning plastics and releasing carcinogens.

E waste also contains valuable metals such as gold. It is estimated that there is more gold in electronics in landfill than all the worlds ores. In fact, the Royal Mint is investing in technology to extract gold from e waste to bolster gold supplies.

Another place where we keep a lot of old electronics is in our drawers. We often hold onto old pieces of technology due to the hassle of recycling and issues around residual sensitive data. Andrew Wright here poses to solve this through greater education on recycling e waste alongside use of software such as blanko- which is designed to make hard drives unreadable.

In order to make IT more sustainable, Andrew Wright proposes four things: for businesses to choose a good ITAD (IT Asset Disposal) provider that is comitted to reuse rather than landfill, for governments to advocate for stronger right to repair and for users to both buy more refurbished technology and repair when possible- the most sustainable device is the one that already exists. So, although IT is bad for the planet, its effects can be mitigated.

Speaker 3- Brendan Hyland

Our third speaker was Brendan Hyland- the CEO of SeabedDC. Brendan here discusses how his company is planning to decarbonise the cloud at scale. His company SeabedDC was setup 3 years ago to explore the creation of a sustainable digital world powered by nature- rather than at natures expense. Today, datacentres (mainly due to the AI boom) are rapidly growing- capacity is set to triple by 2030 and capital expenditure of around $6 trillion is required to do this. Right now, around 20% of datacentre demand is AI. This is set to rise to around 70% by 2030. The problem here is that rapid expansion is being done in a way that is unsustainable- often using fossil fuels. Datacentres now emit more CO2 than the entire aviation industry and require large amounts of water for cooling (often in water stressed regions like Texas).

SeabedDC aims to do things a bit differently. They aim to create a “green AI” cloud service that is powered by nature. They hope to use seawater for cooling- rather than treated water and setup datacentres in unused browfield and harbour sites.

They have two main types of datacentres; underwater datacentres placed under the water (that use seawater to cool them) and more traditional datacentre designs in repurposed roll on roll off ferries. They aim to build over 1 gigawatt of clean AI capacity in the UK by 2035. Each of their hubs aims to have between 100 and 500 megawatt cloud capacity and will be fully sovereign (in country) rather than distributing data around the world. Each location will also act as an anchor for clean energy projects.

Share