A blog by Andrew White based on ACA’s September 2024 Climate Café
Cafe Overview
The focus on this climate café was the Human impact on oceans. Here, two guest speakers- Abbie and Erik spoke about a wide range of topics including harnessing the marine microbiome to improve both human and marine health and using line fishing techniques to prevent overfishing in North Sea waters.

Manipulating the Marine Environment
Firstly, Abbie spoke about how we can adapt and manipulate the marine environment to sustainably provide protein and sequestrate carbon. Proposals here mainly focused on plankton and kelp. However, there was an acknowledgement that manipulating ocean chemistry could end up doing more harm than good to the sensitive marine ecosystem.
For instance, the example of blue carbon was discussed. Blue carbon is a concept where us humans utilise the ocean to store carbon effectively. To achieve this, two ideas were proposed.
- Manipulating the biology of the ocean. Here, this could mean anything- from chemically altering the pH of the ocean to submerging a metal structure (causing the metal to be oxidized and allowing for the grafting of marine plant life.
- Genetically engineering living organisms such as plankton. Cultivating 32 megatons of genetically engineered macroalgae such as plankton can remove up to 88000 tonnes of carbon dioxide yearly. This can then be simply removed from the ocean and stored in a controlled container.
However, there were doubts that these proposals could do more good than potential harm. Firstly, there is little research on large scale ocean manipulation and its effects. Something that may seem to have positive effects could end up causing greater negative effects on marine life- essentially doing more harm than good. Also, genetic engineered organisms could have detrimental effects to marine life health if it escapes and gets into the food chain. Additionally, we are unsure how much carbon leaks out of blue carbon stores- if carbon leaks are high, ocean acidification could become an issue.
Overfishing in the North Sea
The next speaker was Erik, who spoke about his experiences in the fishing industry. Here, Erik spoke about how when he was in the industry, line fishing was commonplace, and fish was plentiful. Then, trawlers started operating in Scottish waters. Once trawlers were permitted, Erik left the industry and predicted that the industry would collapse within five years. Four years later, sooner than expected, Erik was proven right- overfishing by trawlers had severely depleted stocks.
Erik argues for the return to line fishing, citing success in the Bering Sea. In the 80s, the Bering Sea was over trawled so, legislation was introduced to ban trawling. Fast forward to 2014 and the Bering Sea now produces more fish than the North Sea- despite it being significantly smaller.
The main benefit of line fishing is that it does not kill juvenile fish. Trawlers are indiscriminate on the fish caught so; oftentimes juvenile fish are killed before they reach maturity. Line fishing on the other hand makes it so you can discriminate against juveniles- allowing for fish to reach maturity and spawn.
However, there are two main problems with line fishing. The first is that traditionally, line fishing is very labour intensive– requiring up to ten people- whereas trawlers only need two. However, innovations in line fishing technology have allowed for as little as three people to line fish effectively.
The second problem is grey seals. Line fishing is damaging to grey seals- which are a protected species. Erik argues that seals should be stripped of their protected status as they are not native to Scotland however, this would cause conflicts with environmentalists. He also argues that seals consume vast amounts of fish each day- further contributing to depleted stocks.
Overall, Erik argues that there is a need to address overfishing. His suggestion is to revert to less intensive line fishing methods however, this is likely to spark debate with environmentalists- who wish to protect the seal populations.
A recording of the full climate cafe can be found below. Content starts at 4:40.

