Skip to content
Home » Posts » A Regional Vision for a Just Transition

A Regional Vision for a Just Transition


A blog by Andrew White based on ACA’s October 2024 Climate Café


Cafe Overview

This climate café concerned the idea of a just transition. Transitioning towards green energy can be quite contentious due to the potential of widespread job losses- such as what happened when the coal mines were closed in the 1980s. As Aberdeen is a fossil fuel hub, it is of paramount importance that alternative industries move to Aberdeen as we transition away from fossil fuels to ensure that high quality jobs continue in the region.

The Just Transition Lab

The first speaker this month was Daria- the director of the Centre for Energy Law and co-ordinator of the Just Transition Lab at the University of Aberdeen. There are two main roles of the Just Transition Commission. Firstly, there is the sector planning role. Here, they develop plans on energy policy and regional planning for a just transition. Secondly, there is the scrutiny role. Here, plans made by the Scottish Government are scrutinised. Lots of feedback is gathered from impacted communities (in this case, oil and gas members) whilst performing scrutinisation.

Within the just transition lab, the goal is to bring people together to collaborate across different disciplines. The focus is on the North Sea mainly and plans to transition Aberdeen into a low-carbon hub. Some themes discussed with focus groups here included the idea of producing new net-zero jobs, revitalising communities and ensuring that fuel poverty is eliminated within the city and shire.

In order to come up with a good plan to make this happen, the Just Transition Lab had to overcome many challenges. For instance, other de-industrialization projects such as what has occurred at Grangemouth cannot directly transfer to Aberdeen due to a difference in scale. Additionally, oil and gas jobs have fallen dramatically in the city already- from 25,000 in 2015 to 17,000 in 2021. Whilst there has been a rise in renewables employment, currently the number of jobs is not as much as fossil fuels.

From these, they came up with twenty indicators to compile data on- some being more qualitative and others quantitative. For more information on the Just Transition Lab, follow the link below;

https://www.abdn.ac.uk/geosciences/research/just-transition-lab-2101.php

NESCAN Community Action

Next, Nicola spoke about community and place at Nescan. Here, the proposal was to develop collaborative projects that brings communities together. Nescan aims to talk to people and allow communities to influence policy however, this can be difficult as community motivation is challenging. People often have their thoughts about what is right for them, however they may be unwilling to voice them. Nescan engages heavily with communities and helps people realise their skillsets- allowing them to group together and take effective action.

Trade Union Council- Fairness for fossil fuel workers

Finally, Ryan from the Trade Union Council spoke about the need for a just transition from a worker’s perspective. Ryan used some past examples of when collective union action has helped with environmental policy- such as when the Atomic Workers Union in the USA protested a manufacturing site that was harmful for their local environment. Now though, in the face of de-industrialization and the green transition, workers are struggling with job losses. There is a need to do something against climate change however, oftentimes the needs of fossil fuel employees are overlooked. There is also the idea that “business as usual” will fix the climate crisis however, that is what caused the climate crisis in the first place.
As workers are being ignored, they are often taken advantage of. For instance, at Grangemouth, Ineos suddenly transformed a refinery into an import/export venue- causing emissions to be offshored and local job losses. Workers had an alternative proposal to extend the transition period, offer new training on renewable practices and investments in the site however, their ideas were ignored. There is also concerns that there is little cross certification between fossil fuel certifications and renewable certifications so, if a certified oil worker loses their job, it can be difficult to find a new skilled job in renewables.
Ryan proposes more public ownership of assets to facilitate the green transition. Rather than freeports and deregulation, he proposes that ownership of assets such as ports should be transferred to local authorities- such as in Greenland. Additionally, Ryan supports better training on renewables for fossil fuel workers so they can remain in skilled employment.

Share