Skip to content
Home » Posts » December Climate Cafe- The Grid

December Climate Cafe- The Grid

By Andrew White

Introduction

This climate cafe focused on The Grid. Here, the network design of the grid was explained and issues surrounding the new Deeside pylons were discussed by the speakers. We had three guest speakers present this month- Professor Ashley Hastings from the University of Aberdeen discussing how the UK electricity grid works, Sarah Beattie-Smith from SSEN explaining the need for new pylons and John Rahtz from Deeside Against Pylons arguing for alternatives to the new electricity pylons.

Speaker 1- Professor Ashley Hastings

Our first speaker of the night was Professor Ashley Hastings. Professor Hastings discussed how the Grid requires many different energy generation sources operating together in tandem- utilising many different underlying technologies including oil, gas, renewables and nuclear. However, as renewable sources such as wind and solar are inconsistent, there is currently a need for non-renewable sources such as gas to make up shortfalls and deal for peak demand. All of this needs to be co-ordinated in real time to avoid both excessive energy wastage from generating too much electricity and power outages from generating too little. To make up for any shortfall, there is a network of high voltage undersea DC cables connecting the UK to the EU. These cables allows the UK to buy excess electricity from EU member states in times of peak demand.

All of these energy sources need to be outputting to the grid at the same voltage and phase to avoid potential issues. Professor Hastings explained that this needs to be at a high voltage to minimise energy lost to resistance. As Voltage equals Currant times Resistance and Loss equals Current squared times Resistance, reducing currant by a half and doubling voltage leads to four times less energy lost. Because of this, there is the need for both large high voltage electricity lines and step up transformers to increase the voltage output of each energy source to the required amount.

Additionally, due to the need for standardisation on the grid, each source needs to be feeding AC power to the grid. Because of this, some energy sources such as solar (which always output DC power) need to be converted to AC via a DC to AC converter.

In order for consumers to use electricity delivered through the national grid, transformations need to be applied. As very high voltages are extremely dangerous, you cannot directly connect homes to high voltage lines. Due to this, step down transformers are used to provide a safer 230V AC connection to individual households. For factories where a high voltage connection is preferable, private networks are used that run at a higher voltage than home connections.

Speaker 2- Sarah Beattie-Smith

Our next guest speaker was Sarah Beattie-Smith. Sarah is a senior sustainability advisor for SSEN- the company that operate the power transmission lines in Scotland. Here, Sarah argues that power lines are extremely important to connect renewable energy sources in Scotland to England to meet their energy demands. The argument here states that there is less space in England to build renewable energy installations so, it is necessary to transport power down from Scotland. Because of this, Scotland by 2030 is due to produce about 20 percent of the UKs energy demand by 2030- despite only making up around 8 percent of the UKs population. Sarah argues that Scotland is better suited than England due to planning laws on onshore wind farms, favourable conditions for wind farms and Scotland having a lower population density than England.

These plans all contribute to SSEN’s goal of halving emissions by 2030. Sarah argues that large overhead pylons in Deeside are necessary for this due to being able to use lower carbon alternatives for the cables (better for the carbon life cycle of the pylons) and both cost and emisssion savings compared to undersea cabling- citing a study which states that overhead cables cost 23 percent less than their onshore counterparts.

Speaker 3- John Rahtz

Our third and final speaker was John Rahtz from Deeside Against Pylons. John argued that there was a better alternative to the large pylons proposed by SSEN in the form of High Voltage DC undersea cables and generating more electricity in England itself. John argues that SSEN’s claims of jobs due to the new High Voltage lines are inaccurate- saying that only around 15 percent of jobs resulting from the High Voltage lines are local- the rest are in the Chinese steel industry and transportation. Additionally, John argues that the electricity generated is for the South of England hence, it is illogical to generate it in Scotland.

John also believes that undersea cables are a better technical solution. Firstly, he argues that the study Sarah cited regarding cable costs was misleading- only focusing on short, unviable cable runs and outdated. Also, he argues that DC is a superior transmission technology compared to AC so, we should switch to it, as DC allows for safer buried high voltage cables- like they do in Germany.

Another argument against the pylons included interference with agricultural farming. Due to the requirement for clean agricultral equipment in potato growing fields, construction equipment for the pylons is likely to damage crops. Additionally, the high voltage lines mean that crop irrigation cannot be effectively employed near the pylons due to safety concerns.

Additionally, the large pylons are an eyesore and devalue houses. The proposed pylons are 2.5 times taller than Crathes Castle so, will heavily devalue nearby housing. In England, it is illegal to erect pylons on Areas of Outstanding Natural Beauty however, there are no such bans in Scotland. There is also health concerns for residents near the pylons. The new pylons are predicted to create magnetic fields that are four times stronger than the maximum allowed under EU limits. This essentially makes those living close by for guinea pigs regarding high magnetic levels.

Share