By Andrew White.
This climate cafe focused on the topic of community transport. Here, three guest speakers- David Kelly, the Director of the Scottish Community Transport Association, Jenny Milne from the Scottish Rural & Islands Transport Community and Caroline Hood from Nestrans spoke about the definition of community transport, various community transport schemes in use and the benefits of community transport.
Speaker 1- David Kelly
Our first speaker of the night was David Kelly from the Community Transport Association (CTA). David Kelly spoke about what community transport is, what the CTA do and their role in community-led action. David defined community transport schemes as non profit enterprises that are community run for social purpose and to solve unmet transit needs in the area. These schemes are often hyper local and serve over 802,000 passengers yearly. Community transport encompasses many different transport modes including cars, buses and bikes with different communities picking their preferred mode of transport based off community need and geographical practicalities. David also explained that community transport schemes are found both in rural and urban settings. Fourty four percent of community transport schemes are rural with the rest being either urban or island schemes.
Some examples of community transport schemes include the Killin and District car scheme. This is a volunteer-run scheme where volunteers drive elderly and disabled members of the community to places like the shops and to doctors appointments. The scheme was setup due to expensive and unreliable public transport in the Killin area and has helped to tackle exclusion, isolation and lonliness in the region. Another scheme is the Glenfarg Community transport which is a community-run bus service. This non-profit bus service has increased bus ridership in the area by ten percent. A third scheme is the Women on Wheels scheme in Govanhill. As Govanhill is an urban area within Glasgow, bikes were chosen as they were the most cost effective and practical zero-carbon option. Govanhill is a low-income area where many residents have limited access to cars so, the bikes have empowered locals to travel further for opportunities.
Community transport initiatives are also good for the climate as they help to reduce private car use (which is far above Scottish government targets). Two thirds of community transit operators cite climate as part of their mission and eighteen percent of vehicle schemes comprise of EVs. However, electric vehicles are impractical currently in some rural areas due to a lack of charging infrastructure.
Speaker 2- Jenny Milne
Our next speaker was Jenny Milne from the Scottish Rural & Islands Transport Community. Jenny spoke about challenges facing community transport schemes in the highlands and islands. She said that car clubs in particular have struggled with the rising cost of car insurance- particularly since 2020. This has led to a decline of active car clubs as the cost of insurance becomes too large for the clubs to continue operating. For instance, Moray Car Club has seen their car insurance bill increase by over 300%. Schemes such as the Just Transition Fund cover the cost of purchasing vehicles however, they do not cover the insurance.
This has led to car clubs being forced to increase their price and decrease investment into improving their service- or otherwise fold. Legislative solutions are available for some car clubs- it is possible for some social enterprises to get heavily discounted car insurance however, this is only open for operators who own at least three cars. Smaller schemes with one to two cars are not covered by this.
Speaker 3- Caroline Hood
Our final speaker was Caroline Hood from Nestrans- The Regional Transport Partnership (RTP) for North East Scotland. Caroline discussed how nestrans as a charity helps liase between community transit initiatives, Transport Scotland and Aberdeen City / Shire councils. Nestrans produces a regional strategy that focuses on affordability of public transport and aims to improve accessiblity for everyone- particularly in areas underserved by public transport. They engage with local communities to provide the optimal solutions to their problems and help groups to get funding for their endeavours.
Nestrans also recognises the need to investigate more creative solutions for a given community. This is because community transports solutions are not one size fits all- different communities have different needs. For instance, they agreed with Jenny Milne that charging infrastructure was a barrier to electric car clubs in some rural areas. Nestrans also helps with creating the best solution which is both financially and environmentally sustainable for each community in order to have the biggest positive impact.

