A guest blog by Andrew White.
Introduction
In this months climate cafe, we discussed the current economic system and how we may need to adapt it in order to ensure it complies with sustainable development goals. In order to evaluate this, we had three speakers- Ken Thompson who discussed a conventional economists view of the climate crisis, WIlliam Thompson who proposed changes to the economic system with the ongoing climate crisis and Vinishree Solanki- who discussed “doughnut economics”.
Speaker 1- Ken Thompson
Our first speaker this month was Ken Thompson. Ken discussed the nature of how economists view constraints such as climate constraints and how economics and economists care most about product demand. He explained that economic systems often find ways to avert crises in the past through either a more financially viable product becoming available, sociatal backlash or government regulations. For instance, Ken Thompson discussed how bills were passed to prevent timber running out in the Elizabethan times and in the Victorian times, people were worried about the streets being covered in manure due to excessive horses. These fears were dismissed due to the automobile. He then discussed a theory proposed by Simon Kuznets which can be used to show environmental damage based off economic development. This theory, called the Kuznets curve, shows that environmental damage worsens as development begins however, at a certain point, there is a turning point- after which environmental damage decreases as the country further develops and transitions to a service-based economy.
Ken Thompson finally showed what can be done to improve the sustainablity of the economic system without fundamentally altering it. For instance, he proposed a deep focus on the overall issues, having a plan instead of blindly seeking “change” and emphasize relevant data to help make progress. Ken Thompson also suggested regulations to prevent consumption and taxes/subsidies to encourage/discourage their usage however, he also said to only do this when necessary to avoid upsetting the economic system.
Speaker 2- William Thompson
Our second speaker was William Thompson who spoke about how we can make our economic system more sustainable. William Thompson discussed how classical neoliberal economics can have a sustainability “sweet spot” however, we have largely ignored this in our economy. Due to this, we are either close to or, have exceeded environmental limits. William Thompson described something called “heterodox economics”. This theory claims that the economy is bounded by external forces- such as the environment. Hence, there cannot be infinite growth (as more traditional economists believe). The argument here is that we need a system that accounts for environmental limits. Since around the 1970s, we have had a “full world” economic system. This means that we are bound by the damage to the environment- the world is at capacity and we can no longer “dump” our waste unbounded. As we are both extracting and dumping too much from the earth, we need to consume in a way that is responsible- not “infinite growth” consumption.
Speaker 3- Vinishree Solanki
Our third and final speaker was Vinishree Solanki who explained the concept of “doughnut economics”. Vinishree Solanki has a background in working with ethnic minority groups to design climate frameworks that promote social justice- such as the Creative Dundee project.
The Doughnut economic model is made up of two concentric rings- a smaller social foundation ring (which is bad if we fall below as this indicates social inequalities) and a larger ecological ceiling (which we should not overshoot). If the economic system grows too much, it overshoots past the ecological ceiling. Currently, our system overshoots in some areas and has shortfalls in others. So that we can reach the social foundation ring and stay under the economic ring in all metrics, Vinishree suggests that we work with natural processes with regenerative methods and redistribute wealth in a fairer and more equitable way. She also suggests bringing together those from underrepresented backgrounds in order to drive positive change and lower inequalities.
For more information on doughnut economics, visit the Doughnut Economics Action Lab (DEAL)

