By Andrew White
Introduction
In this climate cafe, we explored how plant-based materials can be used in place of traditional alternatives. We looked at both Timber in the Construction industry with talks from Carola Calcagno and David Cleverley of Glenalmond Timber and plant-based alternatives to oil-based plastics with a talk by Dr Davide Dionisi from the University of Aberdeen.
Talk One- How Timber can be used in Construction by Carola Calcagno- Glenalmond Timber
Our first talk of the evening was by Carola Calcagno from Glenalmond Timber. Carola disussed how by 2050, 70% of the worlds population will live in urban areas (up from 56% today) and the worlds population will increase to 9.7 billion (up from 8 billion today)- meaning cities will expand significantly. To accomodate this surge in growth, we need sustainable materials for new buildings and refurbishments. Currently, 42% of CO2 emissions come from the built environment- 27% of global emissions from building operations and a further 15% from cement, steel, iron and aluminium production.
From graphs shown by Carola, metals such as stainless steel and aluminium have the highest amount of embodied carbon per kilogram. After these metals, we have plastics, glass and bricks and concrete. Yet, Carolas graph shows something interesting with using timber as a building material. Because trees absorb CO2 as they grow, timber has a negative embodied carbon. In fact, this photosynthesis offsets the processing and transport required to make timber products.
If you consider all building materials by volume consumed worldwide, concrete is by far the most used building material. So despite having comparatively little embodied carbon per kilogram compared to metals, plastics and glass, globally concrete production produces the most carbon emissions. In some cases, timber can be used instead of concrete. Most timber products consumed in the UK are PEFC certified- meaning they are sustainably sourced. The manufacture of timber products for construction produces very little waste as timber waste can be easily recycled.
Timber is an ideal building material as it is light but strong. Compared to competing materials, timber is easier to transport and move and requires less foundations. You can also use timber to build vertical extensions on top of existing buildings (for example, 55 Southbank Bvld in Melbourne was expanded upwards using timber). Timber is also good for prefabricated buildings as it is fast to build and flexible in design.
Finally, timbers natural qualities is good for thermal and acoustic performance. Timber has natural insulating properties and helps reduce noise. As timber is relatively cheap to produce, easy to work with, requires less foundations, is compatible with the circular economy and meets current Environmental Impact Assessment standards, it is seen as an ideal building material for the future of construction. Furthermore, timber is very versitile- from solid wood products to specially engineered products and thermally modified timber.
Yet, there are challenges including fire safety, moisture durability and engineering design challenges. However, despite these challenges they can be effectively mitigated- which David Cleverley speaks about next.
Talk Two- Proving Timber to be a Safe Alternative by David Cleverley- Glenalmond Timber and Intelligent Wood Systems
According to David, timber is often chosen by clients for many reasons, including strength, aesthetics, cost, durability, useability and planning consents. However, many clients are worried about what happens during a building fire. David Cleverley in this talk dispels some of these fears and shows how timber is just as safe- if not more so- in terms of fire safety compared to other, more polluting alternatives.
Fires are undeniably an issue for timber however, fire is also an issue materials such as concrete- which weakens above 300 degrees, stainless steel- which buckles above 550 degrees and light-gauge steel- which completely fails around 900 degrees. These temperatures are often reached within building fires. Most building fires are caused when there is excessive heat or spark near a fuel source. When the excessive heat or spark ignites the fuel source, as long as there is ample oxygen, a fire starts. Within a building, there are two types of fire; the first one is during the buildings construction (where you want to be able to manage and control the fire as much as possible) and the second is when the building is In Service (where the focus is on keeping the fire out of the buildings habitable areas for as long as possible so people can escape).
So during construction is when buildings are in is the skeletal stage, a pod is created to test fire safety. This pod represents a mini unit. The challenge is to keep the pods structural integrity and keep the fire contained within the pod. Timber products can be treated with flame retardant materials to help contain the blaze- helping them to keep their structural integrity.
The goal of the test is to ensure the outside of the building does not allow fire to travel- no fire spread and as little structural damage as possible. So although timber will burn, it is no worse than other alternative materials like steel and it can be treated with chemicals to reduce flammability. Although timber is an old material, thanks to its durability it can be the green construction resource of the future.
Talk Three- Biodegradable Plastics from Organic Waste by Dr Davide Dionisi- University of Aberdeen
The third speaker at the cafe was Dr Davide Dionisi- who spoke about creating bioplastic alternatives from organic waste. From over 25 yrs of industry and research experience, Dr Dionisi aims to commercialize bioplastics made from orgainc waste.
Currently, most plastics come from CO2 producing sources such as oil. This means each year, 480 megatonnes of fossil carbon is embedded in organic chemicals and materials (including plastics) per year. The yearly value of conventional plastics and organic acids produced globally is around 700 billion dollars per year. To make much of these, Fossil resources are used. Many important products including cleaning chemicals, paracetamol and shampoo depend on active ingredients from fossil resources. Currently we use fossil resources and non renewable energy to make chemicals and plastic. However, this causes ecological damage and one day, we will run out of fossil fuel resources. We require renewable feedstocks and renewable energy to make sustainable, low-carbon chemicals that do as little ecological damage as possible to allow sustainable production into the future.
Within these chemicals, plastics are a specific issue as they are generally not biodegradable. Dr Davide Dionisi is interested in Polyhydroxyalkanoates (PHA) plastics. Unlike traditional plastics such as polyethlene (which is made from fossil fuels), these plastics are biodegradable and made from biomass aerobic fermentation with pure cultures and solvent extraction. Today, there are some PHA products however, they are uncommon. Also, PHAs are very expensive compared to normal plastics due to the need for virgin biomass.
Hence, Dr Dionisi wants to use food waste, manure and sewage in anaerobic digesters instead to create PHAs. Over 20 years of research, his team has been able to make PHAs profitable- with production costs at-scale being similar to polyethylene. He plans to create trial plants and then, consider commercializing the technology if it goes well.
Compared to other fossil-fuel produced plastics, PHAs are highly rigid. In terms of stretchiness, PHAs are similar to their alternatives- making them good for packaging. PHAs also have a high carrying capacity, making them good for loads and a low permeability of oxygen- making them ideal for food preservation. Yet, compared to other plastics PHAs are brittle.
Compared to other bioplastics such as PLA, PHAs are significantly more biodegradable. PLA is only poorly biodegradable under anaerobic digestion, whereas PHAs are fully compostable. Additionally, PLA must be separated from other plastics in order for it to be recycled. Meanwhile, PHAs can be mixed with other organic wastes and send to anaerobic fermentation.

